Position-by-Position Comparison of the 2010 and 2014 USA Olympic Hockey Teams

By (NHL National Columnist) on January 26, 2014

46,288 reads

52Icon_comment

Previous
1 of 9
Next
Hi-res-96937446-team-usa-celebrate-after-brian-rafalski-of-the-united_crop_650x440
Jamie Squire/Getty Images

Four years ago in Vancouver, Team USA came within a single goal of winning Olympic gold. Sidney Crosby scored the winner in overtime of the tournament's final game, when it could very easily have gone the other way.

Can the 2014 group do better? How do they compare to their predecessors? Read on for a position-by-position breakdown of the two teams.

All statistics are courtesy of IIHF.com. For more pieces by Jonathan Willis, follow him on Twitter

 

Left Wing

Hi-res-96844526-zach-parise-of-the-united-states-during-the-ice-hockey_crop_650
Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Zach Parise
  • Patrick Kane
  • Ryan Malone
  • Bobby Ryan

2014 Team:

  • Zach Parise
  • Patrick Kane
  • James van Riemsdyk
  • Max Pacioretty

Summary: The big guns are the same as they were in Vancouver, with Parise still in the heart of his career and Kane now an experienced 25 rather than a callow 21. 

The depth players have different names, but provide similar skills to the 2010 group, with van Riemsdyk replacing Malone's size and Pacioretty supplying Ryan's goal-scoring. 

Centre

Hi-res-97177768-ryan-kesler-of-the-united-states-controls-the-puck-on_crop_650
Bruce Bennett/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Ryan Kesler
  • Paul Stastny
  • Joe Pavelski
  • David Backes
  • Chris Drury

2014 Team:

  • Ryan Kesler
  • Joe Pavelski
  • David Backes
  • Paul Stastny
  • Derek Stepan

Summary: The cast is virtually unchanged, with the only movement in the "spare" centre department, with current New York Ranger Derek Stepan replacing retired New York Ranger Chris Drury. 

The top four players are now in their late 20s after playing in Vancouver in their mid-20s. Some are a little better now than then, others a little worse, but there is not much difference in terms of overall ability here. 

Right Wing

Hi-res-96935306-phil-kessel-of-the-united-states-is-seen-during-warmups_crop_650
Harry How/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Jamie Langenbrunner
  • Dustin Brown
  • Phil Kessel
  • Ryan Callahan

2014 Team:

  • Phil Kessel
  • T.J. Oshie
  • Dustin Brown
  • Ryan Callahan
  • Blake Wheeler

Summary: Three of Team USA's forwards return, but Kessel is a much better player than he was in Vancouver, an elite weapon today when he was only a supporting player back then. He gives the American side a more solid, experienced option at the position than it had in 2010.

The rest of the roster is arguably a saw-off; Oshie is a strong addition, but Langenbrunner played well in 2010.

Left Defence

Hi-res-97027047-ryan-suter-of-the-united-states-in-action-during-the-ice_crop_650
Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Ryan Suter
  • Brooks Orpik
  • Tim Gleason
  • Ryan Whitney

2014 Team:

  • Ryan Suter
  • Ryan McDonagh
  • Brooks Orpik
  • Cam Fowler

Summary: Suter returns in the leading role, but the depth behind him is dramatically improved from 2010. Cam Fowler, the No. 4 on the left side for the 2014 team, would arguably have been in the No. 2 slot in Vancouver, and McDonagh is a huge asset the Americans did not have last time. 

 

 

Right Defence

Hi-res-97177093-brian-rafalski-of-the-united-states-skates-with-the-puck_crop_650
Alex Livesey/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Brian Rafalski
  • Jack Johnson
  • Erik Johnson

2014 Team:

  • Paul Martin
  • John Carlson
  • Kevin Shattenkirk
  • Justin Faulk

Summary: Rafalski is a huge loss; he was named the top defenceman at the 2010 tournament, and the Americans could really use him again. On the other hand, Martin's health is a big win, particularly since it gives Team USA a fuller slate of right-shooting rearguards. 

The depth overall is better, too. Both Johnsons were eligible for this year's team and were passed over in favour of other options. Still, with Rafalski gone, the Americans do not have the same punch at the top end of the depth chart. 

 

Goalie

Hi-res-96754414-goalie-ryan-miller-of-the-united-states-keeps-an-eye-on_crop_650
Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images

2010 Team:

  • Ryan Miller
  • Tim Thomas
  • Jonathan Quick

2014 Team:

  • Ryan Miller
  • Jonathan Quick
  • Jimmy Howard

Summary: The starting job this year is up for grabs; Quick is the consensus favourite, but Miller has had a superb season for a terrible team and could very well play his way into the top job during the round-robin phase. 

Even for Miller, though, it will be difficult to match his standout performance in 2010, when he posted a 0.946 save percentage and was named MVP of the Olympic hockey tournament.

Final Analysis

Hi-res-96936305-team-usa-celebrate-after-brian-rafalski-of-the-united_crop_650
Harry How/Getty Images

How do the groups compare overall?

At left wing and centre, it is mostly a wash; the players are largely the same, and those who are not play similar games. At right wing it is tempting to say the same, but the emergence of Phil Kessel as a truly elite talent makes that impossible; he gives the Americans a weapon they did not have last time.

On defence, the Americans are down one exceptional defenceman in Brian Rafalski, but are dramatically improved in terms of depth and should be better overall for that reason. In net, the names are solid, but Ryan Miller was so good last time that it is difficult to imagine anyone matching that performance.

The 2014 group is probably the better team, but will face a steep challenge to better the work of the 2010 silver-medal-winning squad. 

Begin Slideshow
Keep Reading
Flag
Props (0)
This article is

What is the duplicate article?

Why is this article offensive?

Where is this article plagiarized from?

Why is this article poorly edited?

Flag This Article
Default-user-icon-comment
or to post a comment

52 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment
Big
Loading comments...
just now posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

Team StreamTM

Olympics

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.